Constructive Criticism: 7 Ways It Empowers Creativity
If repetition is the mother of learning, constructive criticism is the secret to growth. Individuals who choose a growth mindset often look for different types of point-of-view. While they understand the importance of their personal perspective, they welcome others’ perspectives, whether it is in the form of positive or even negative feedback.
Before we discuss the ways this form of criticism aids in creativity, it’s crucial to define exactly what it is.
What Is Constructive Criticism?
Constructive criticism is feedback given to another to aid growth. For creative writers, beta readers often fall into this category.
For instance, a beta reader will read a writer’s work and note details such as the following:
If the story is told in an engaging way
What they did and did not like about the protagonist (lead character in the story)
If they felt immersed in the character’s thoughts
Overall likes or dislikes of the plot
Beta readers can prove invaluable as they provide constructive feedback on the story. The same can be said for software beta testers, friends who assess your body language as you prepare for your next speech, or a boss explaining how you can better fulfill your role requirements.
How To Differentiate Between Criticism And Constructive Criticism?
While the answer to this question is subjective, the question itself reveals quite a bit about a person’s point of view. Imagine we ask the following: “Criticism is criticism, so how do we differentiate between criticism intended for positive feedback versus criticism as personal attacks?”
For someone focused on growth and empowering their creative endeavors, they will use any feedback they can get to improve. Whether a person provides feedback with the sandwich method (one positive, one negative, one positive) or needs to learn tips for giving constructive criticism, their thoughts are helpful.
Let’s dive into ways constructive criticism can benefit you, your creative endeavors, and your career as a whole.
#1 - Shows You A New Point Of View
When someone takes the time to give you feedback, that person enlarges your viewpoint of your work. Recently, a client explained he was too close to his project and wanted my opinion on his work. This takes humility and vulnerability. However, in asking for my thoughts, he broadened his point of view on how others see his work. I’ve had to do the same, and it’s always helpful.
#2 - Helps You Build A Thick Skin For Future Success
The more successful you become, the higher the possibility of someone disliking your work. For instance, if your short story wins first place in a contest, your new status will likely be celebrated by many but explained away by some.
“She didn’t write an empathetic protagonist.”
“His villain was such a trope.”
“What a slow burn.”
These comments can hurt, but remember this is one person’s narration, perspective, and viewpoint of your writing. Instead, ask yourself the following:
Should my protagonist be more empathetic?
Did I make my villain seem human, or are they right in a few areas?
Should I jump into the action sooner, or did the slow burn work?
Developing a thick skin can help you receive criticism well and use it for your good.
#3 - Reveals Potential Issues Early
A third way constructive criticism can aid in your creativity is by alerting you to issues before it’s too late. While creativity is a very subjective field and there are countless ways to write books, craft characters, and formulate plots, early feedback can be extremely helpful.
If a beta reader catches a plot hole or character inconsistency early, you save yourself quite a bit of rewriting time. Asking for feedback, especially early on, can feel vulnerable, but the rewards are worth it.
#4 - Teaches You Leadership Styles
The more you learn to accept feedback and grow from it, the stronger of a leader you become. Especially for nonfiction, becoming a thought leader in your genre is a big asset. You may want to become the author that readers search out for advice on your particular topic.
However, becoming a leader in your genre takes time. The more you can listen to what others say, good or bad, the faster you set yourself up for success.
#5 - Builds Empathy In A Narcissistic World
With the word gaslighting becoming the most-searched word of 2022 and the topic of narcissism gracing Business Insider’s website, it’s not a surprise that empathy is strongly lacking. This is true even in the creative space.
How you respond and engage with others shows more about you than you may realize.
If a new writer comes to you with feedback on your work, accepting their thoughts with humility reveals your character, passion to learn, and genuine desire to present your topic in the best way you can.
#6 - Moves Focus To The Details
Reviews, testimonials, and blurbs often focus on the big picture: A reader loved your characterization, your plot was spell-binding, or your final twist was a huge surprise.
When you take the time to listen to constructive criticism, it’s as if you get to listen in to an omniscient narrator talking through your book.
Great writing, and great art as a whole, is in the details. When someone takes the time to say, “That line of dialogue didn’t seem to fit with that character,” they help you become a stronger writer.
Details matter, and often, constructive criticism is where details come to light.
#7 - Keeps You Growing
Whether you have written for days or decades, creatives can always grow in their chosen craft. Whether you attend writing contests, conferences, competitions, or something else, soak up the feedback and learn from it.
You stop growing when you stop learning. Some of the best learning comes from constructive criticism.
By Choosing Feedback, You Choose Growth
Choosing growth is not always an easy choice. Just like the gym member who knows they must break down the muscle in order to strengthen it, creatives must accept feedback to obtain growth.
Feedback comes in a variety of ways. While looking through your online reviews may not be the most healthy choice, asking beta readers for feedback, working with a writing coach, or joining a writing community are all great ways to find healthy criticism that contributes to your growth.
After all, if we’re working to better our work rather than reach a state of perfection, feedback is the key.
“I think it’s very important to have a feedback loop, where you’re constantly thinking about what you’ve done and how you could be doing it better.” —Elon Musk
